Exhaust gas cleaning body Clean Shipping Alliance (CSA) has responded to the announcement of a forthcoming exhaust gas scrubber ban by Greenland.
CSA Executive Director Andreas Chrysostomou said: “We are disappointed to see Greenland announce restrictions on exhaust gas cleaning systems (EGCS, or ‘scrubbers’), starting in 2027. Of course, protecting the Arctic’s sensitive marine environment is important, no question. What we haven’t yet understood, though, is what specific risk Greenland has identified from EGCS in its waters, and how that risk was assessed. The IMO’s MEPC.1/Circ.899 provides an agreed method for evaluating local risk, including the receiving environment, discharge composition, dilution and ecotoxicity. If Greenland has conducted an assessment to support its planned restrictions, we urge them to publish it. If no assessment has been conducted under these guidelines, the case for the restrictions has not been established through the IMO’s framework. A precautionary approach – which is likely the case in Greenland, as in most other places with scrubber restrictions — cannot replace the assessment that the IMO framework calls for.
“The IMO’s risk characterisation and assessment are conducted using the same or similar internationally accepted methods that many countries use to evaluate the acceptability of other discharges for licensing. These IMO-aligned assessments therefore use processes familiar to technical experts in each country. Where these assessments have been carried out, the recently published, peer-reviewed Puget Sound study being one example, they have found low or negligible risk under real operating conditions. That is no surprise, it just reinforces the importance of assessing discharges in context. What would be a surprise is if there is an announced restriction before there has been any assessment of EGCS in Greenland’s waters.
“Greenland’s plans would extend restrictions to territorial seas, beyond OSPAR’s current recommendation, and add closed-loop and hybrid systems from 2029. Operators are entitled to know what the restrictions are based on and what specific risk each phase addresses, with different systems and operating modes assessed on their own evidence.
“The call for the IMO to adopt a global ban, starting in the Arctic, is ultimately a call to change international regulation. Regrettably, Greenland is not alone, and most, if not all, countries with existing EGCS restrictions have also not conducted an IMO-aligned evaluation. We must conclude that these decisions are not based solely on recognized science. Regulation 4 of MARPOL Annex VI recognises EGCS as an equivalent means of compliance. If governments want to change that, the proper route is a transparent amendment at the IMO, supported by location-specific evidence, not a series of regional bans that pre-empt the discussion at PPR 14.
“The most common objection is that scrubbers simply move pollution from air to sea. In reality, EGCS remove sulphur and other substances from exhaust gases, reducing their release to air, where they pose the greatest health risk, and depositing them to sea, where they are already naturally present and quickly revert to background concentrations.
“EGCS can also significantly reduce particulate matter in exhaust emissions, as well as PAHs and metals. This is particularly relevant near land, including in ports and harbours.
“The same substances found in scrubber discharge are also present in the air emissions of non-EGCS ships. This means proposals such as the Nuuk-Reykjavik green corridor, which would rely on MGO, are not an impact-free alternative. In fact, CE Delft’s 2021 well-to-wake analysis found that refining MGO increases lifecycle CO2 emissions by 10-25%, while operating EGCS adds 1.0-1.5%. A 2025 well-to-wake study submitted to the IMO as PPR 13/INF.6 found that HFO used with EGCS delivers equal or lower overall environmental impacts than VLSFO and MGO across most categories. A green corridor relying on MGO therefore cannot be assumed to deliver a better overall environmental outcome than continued EGCS use, including for the marine environment.
“Assessments should compare complete fuel pathways, not a visible discharge against an alternative assumed to have no impact.”
Image: CSA Executive Director Andreas Chrysostomou (source: Clean Shipping Alliance)



